SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
RAMSEY v ANNESLEY COLLEGE
[2013] SASC 72
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue
17 May 2013
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS - CONTRACT IMPLIED FROM CONDUCT OF PARTIES
EMPLOYMENT LAW - CONTRACT OF SERVICE - TERMS OF CONTRACT - IMPLIED TERMS
EMPLOYMENT LAW - TERMINATION AND BREACH OF CONTRACT - GROUNDS - MISCONDUCT - GENERALLY
EMPLOYMENT LAW - TERMINATION AND BREACH OF CONTRACT - REMEDIES - AGAINST EMPLOYER
DAMAGES - MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT - GENERAL
Ms Ramsey was employed by Annesley College as Head of Boarding from 2003 under formal employment contracts executed in 2002 and 2005. In mid 2009, there were discussions concerning a further three or five year contract after expiration of the current contract in January 2010. The discussions were confirmed, to an extent, by letters from Annesley to Ms Ramsey. There was discussion about preparation of a formal contract. Ms Ramsey contends and Annesley denies that by the conversations or letters or by their conduct the parties entered into a three or five year contract of employment. Ms Ramsey continued to be employed by Annesley beyond the 31 January 2010 expiration of the 2005 contract. Annelsey accepts that an implied contract arose but for no fixed term and terminable on notice.
In November 2009, the Deputy Head of Boarding made a complaint about Ms Ramsey’s conduct. Annesley conducted an investigation subsequently expanded to encompass other allegations about Ms Ramsey’s conduct. Ms Ramsey contends that Annesley breached the implied term of mutual trust and confidence (and another alleged implied term) in the conduct of that investigation.
In March 2010, Annesley purported to dismiss Ms Ramsey summarily on the ground that she was guilty of serious misconduct. Ms Ramsey contends that Annesley had no grounds for summary dismissal and thereby breached and repudiated the contract. She also contends that Annesley dismissed her for an ulterior motive of saving expenses.
Ms Ramsey claims damages comprising 12 weeks’ remuneration, loss of the opportunity to remain at Annesley, loss of the opportunity to gain employment elsewhere in the teaching profession, mitigatory expenditure and damages for distress.
HELD:
1. The parties did not enter into a three or five year contract in 2009 or 2010 (at [143]-[176]).
2. The parties by their conduct entered into a contract of employment for no fixed term, terminable on 12 weeks’ notice, with effect from 1 February 2010 (at [177]-[187]).
3. It was not a term of the contract that Annesley would comply with its Complaints Policy (at [193-[209]).
4. Annesley did not breach the implied term of mutual trust and confidence in the conduct of the investigation (at [337]-[369]).
5. Annesley did not dismiss Ms Ramsey summarily acting under an ulterior motive of reducing expenses (at [370]-[378]).
6. Ms Ramsey was not guilty of misconduct. Annesley had no grounds to terminate the contract summarily. Annesley breached and repudiated the contract in purporting to dismiss Ms Ramsey…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ramsey v Annesley College and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] SASC 72
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case included the formation and terms of the employment contract between the parties, whether the College breached any implied terms of the contract, and the grounds for and consequences of any alleged breach. The court needed to determine whether there was a contract of employment for a fixed term or if the employment was terminable on notice, whether the College breached the implied term of mutual trust and confidence during the investigation into the allegations against Ms Ramsey, and whether Ms Ramsey was guilty of misconduct justifying summary dismissal.
The court found that the parties did not enter into a fixed-term contract but rather had an employment relationship terminable on 12 weeks' notice. The court also found that the College did not breach the implied term of mutual trust and confidence during the investigation and that Ms Ramsey was not guilty of misconduct. Consequently, the College's purported summary dismissal of Ms Ramsey was unlawful. Ms Ramsey was awarded 12 weeks' remuneration and long service leave. However, the court held that she was not entitled to damages for the loss of a valuable opportunity to obtain alternative employment due to the College's breach because she failed to prove that such an opportunity existed. Additionally, Ms Ramsey was not entitled to recover her legal costs as mitigatory expenditure or damages for distress. The court ordered that Ms Ramsey was entitled to judgment for $47,081.95, with further orders to be determined.
Orders
Orders of the court
HELD:
1. The parties did not enter into a three or five year contract in 2009 or 2010 (at [143]-[176]).
2. The parties by their conduct entered into a contract of employment for no fixed term, terminable on 12 weeks’ notice, with effect from 1 February 2010 (at [177]-[187]).
3. It was not a term of the contract that Annesley would comply with its Complaints Policy (at [193-[209]).
4. Annesley did not breach the implied term of mutual trust and confidence in the conduct of the investigation (at [337]-[369]).
5. Annesley did not dismiss Ms Ramsey summarily acting under an ulterior motive of reducing expenses (at [370]-[378]).
6. Ms Ramsey was not guilty of misconduct. Annesley had no grounds to terminate the contract summarily. Annesley breached and repudiated the contract in purporting to dismiss Ms Ramsey summarily (at [270]-[336]).
7. Ms Ramsey is entitled, in debt or alternatively in damages, to payment of 12 weeks’ remuneration and long service leave totalling $47,081.95 (at [381]-[386]).
8. There is no reason in principle why Ms Ramsey could not recover the value of a lost opportunity to continue at Annesley (at [389]-[403]). However, on the facts, Annesley would not have continued to employ Ms Ramsey in any event and no damages are recoverable (at [404]-[412]).
9. Ms Ramsey is not entitled in principle to recover as damages for the breach comprising wrongful termination the value of a lost opportunity to obtain employment elsewhere in the teaching profession (at [437]-[458]). She would have been entitled in principle to recover such damages for breach of the mutual trust and confidence term, but she failed to prove breach of that term (at [461]-[475]). In any event, she failed to prove that she had a valuable opportunity which was lost or reduced due to Annesley’s breach of contract (at [477]-[491]).
10. Ms Ramsey is not entitled to recover her costs of action as mitigatory expenditure because the head of loss avoided or reduced by such expenditure is not recoverable (at [492]-[494]).
11. Ms Ramsey is not entitled to recover damages for distress because her claim does not fall within the exceptions identified in Baltic Shipping Co v Dillon (at [496]-[505]).
12. Ms Ramsey is entitled to judgment for $47,081.95 with the parties to be heard as to other orders (at [506]-[513]).
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.