Parliamentary
Archives,
HL/PO/JU/4/3/1155
HOUSE OF LORDS
KOUFOS
v.
C. CZARNIKOW LIMITED
Lord Reid
Lord
Morris
of Borth-y-
Gest
Lord
Hodson
Lord Pearce
Lord
Upjohn
Lord Reid
my lords
By charter
Party of 15th October, 1960 the Respondents chartered the
Appellant's
Vessel, Heron II, to proceed to Constanza, there to load a cargo
of
3,000 tons of sugar; and to carry it to Basrah, or, in the
Charterer's option,
to Jeddah. The vessel left Constanza on 1st
November. The option was
not exercised and the vessel arrived at
Basrah on 2nd December The Umpire
has found that " a
reasonably accurate prediction of the length of the voyage
"
was twenty days ". But the vessel had in breach of contract made
deviations
which caused a delay of nine days.
It was the
intention of the Respondents to sell the sugar " promptly
after
" arrival at Basrah and after inspection by merchants
". The Appellant did
not know this but he was aware of the
fact that there was a market for sugar
at Basrah. The sugar was in
fact sold at Basrah in lots between 12th and 22nd
December but
shortly before that time the market price had fallen partly by
reason
of the arrival of another cargo of sugar. It was found by the
Umpire
that if there had not been this delay of nine days the
sugar would have fetched
£32 10s. Od. per ton. The actual
price realised was only £31 2s. 9d. per ton.
The Respondents
claim that they are entitled to recover the difference as
damage
for breach of contract. The Appellant admits that he is liable to
pay
interest for nine days on the value of the sugar and certain
minor expenses but
denies that fall in market value can be taken
into account in assessing damages
in this case.
McNair J.,
following the decision in The Parana L.R. 2 PD 118,
decided
this question in favour of the Appellant. He said:
" In
those circumstances it seems to me almost impossible to say that
"
the shipowner must have known that the delay in prosecuting the
"
voyage would probably result, or be likely to result, in this kind of
loss."
The Court
of Appeal by a majority (Diplock and Salmon L.JJ., Sellers
L.J.
dissenting) reversed the decision of the trial judge. The
majority held that
The Parana laid down no general rule,
and, applying the rule (or rules) in
Hadley and Another v.
Baxendale and Others (1854) 9 Ex 341 as explained in
Victoria
Laundry (Windsor) Ltd. v. Newman Industries Ltd. [1949] 2
K.B 528,
they held that the loss due to fall in market price was
not too remote to be
recoverable as damages.
It may be
well first to set out the knowledge and intention of the
parties
at the time of making the contract so far as relevant or argued to
be
relevant. The Charterers intended to sell the sugar in the
market at Basrah
on arrival of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read C Czarnikow Ltd v Koufos (The Heron II) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1967] UKHL 4
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi