Choudhuri v Whight

Case [2011] QCATA 193


%PDF-1.5

%????

1 0 obj

<</Type/Catalog/Pages 2 0 R/Lang(en-US) /StructTreeRoot 24 0 R/MarkInfo<</Marked true>>>>

endobj

2 0 obj

<</Type/Pages/Count 3/Kids[ 3 0 R 14 0 R 21 0 R] >>

endobj

3 0 obj

<</Type/Page/Parent 2 0 R/Resources<</XObject<</Image5 5 0 R>>/Font<</F1 6 0 R/F2 8 0 R/F3 10 0 R/F4 12 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<</Type/Group/S/Transparency/CS/DeviceRGB>>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>>

endobj

4 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 2948>>

stream

x??[[o??~???G??Z/??X,?:n7E???,
?>8??H???fO???J?h???[??f??\?‑.V???x?~???p??­&????p???`??yrp>???F??|?????Q??????<???$?D?????S%??i???it?I???]??}????q??w??r??H??e:?2?
,??=?????=`?6???7??l?????9*??|????????Y????P??.1I‑?9??‑??????:??t???w+"]??$?Ss?n??

?D
F?y'?l1????_l?5

D?????K?H?j???a/
C!????????????J?&?
f??XD?:?y?[??x,"????Dm?DdI$8?+??????^?
{2?

??????4L[1]????_HB????*Xm???R?&2??lC?~?*?3???0

?A????JPq????~?|[?­?6?@????
????(?????w3ME?k­????3eq+?8Sk?n???s??

??\???6<?TP??H?@??`@???‑6-??(-={\T?‑???
???z?R?????I-
9??T?L?z`??M????R?:~
??9??@"#??o)?%<y?%Z6??+4?YN8??J?7?<?=?‑H???|l???????S??v??~???48???????Ls????O??R??O??O‑6-~???r??O$??O???????Qu%q?-??I??????r?;??<??D&?????+?6i?J^??D????,#x?g?; w6????+??????U??????9???_j?/????Y???4???`??.?"?1?h-?

????M??????z?u?R^?<w??

a??*??

?K??e?#%m]{.Z?
?mZ??q?yW?+]??*Z?#???v+?d?uX??o?[???IK?K???6????? B????J???=??????i?C??K6?o???C?Y??l?='?-??2RI!G$I?3??\Uc>??
?ub?{?Fy??G?&??­?

8?V??C??;?2AcU?????????e???????qQ[­?~aG?]A6????b$??9iu????VH?J?Fpk??

lUV?B?gH*#?????)J??UK*???\???????bI??bdc?%????Q???????#???D??[???)????E@u?-?G????O?)4xZ?`?P?
???6?d???<$?C?M%<?e{?J?TV?????5?l?;2jP??J]???+????<eg?C?N_?b?I?#[?Z?V??}?u\?.??)?????tLp5Z????=B?M_B?
??????H???|A?26$????P???[TUJ???g??Pv???m2?"Q?q^?b5bW?F????<??<??4?{?-???e???????
KH??B8????c?B?@Sc??MJ?Q???'????5?????Qor?Y??s‑zY?Z?A'?"­xi???ZF}^NU???x?????

?:5?????=N????h3]
??????u????Q???­?{??T??cw?E?l?9r??X??[1]?
m8>ZO????
????>?n?-?,&7-??4?,??'T_C??????????h?????G?3??6?6gv?-?????`??d2B?!1?}?j?L[??[1],?w\L0??~????7n#? k??]?*?#N?-??????????
?Q?.u??
S&O3&#??:?n9?oa??q??m}?~L???q?p+?>CT_1@%?p??.-?6???S?BS?Z?i?#e???EZ'V?6I2?]??o???H?????A\w?M7??<?<n4????)??@|?8?Ad??O_?x???A??@>73*?z
?
???r??1?/???[1]?NoH??J??e?km?y?LDI?r???????N?T?mp?Ip?????
4Q\^??;?"c?????q?y???\?P?TGY?????D!??h??????w?st??????V^B?]GM?????[1]????
5?|???~?????r?u
[1]?????u?5?

7??!?h ?????P????%???????[1]?­^j?y??z?v????c?k'??V:nK?5 ?6 ?[
.8???`??????????[1]??w^D???9?*??Q?S??1????

???zH????w?
?Fs[??]5?i??,`?W!??(I`?C???‑?{0K???V???F??{????R??????)?r?}????????wO?a?????Q8?n?????<??.?
???:??
?w??X???/D?????I(?Efk?yg/???Y?????t?mp?7"x'?p?&?\L]2??Oh?`?j??D?­?U?<???T?E2Y?2??z?H?*7­???>O$hV~?h????*?????em‑??iXR???cT|n??E:??????5]=?n:??Q?z?,??x5???d?Z?4?? ???

?`??E?

?e??n????j?Z?????Ml?5???????L??????

????Ux?a??]???|??9Q?]o?:??C<P­0ls??FW???u?9?h?n?
{?c????qW$?z?V@GZ!?e??? ??? ???K???s/?`J??-?~u???9_M???dm?g=?Z84?x?'???5???9?????????xu;‑?­

?c/?1?‑??v??r????? ?Y#p??

??WU?o?[1]b??A?????[1]?}o???0?I?k<\[1]|L????y

????H­)?????????Pt?7[???0+yyh??vSe?t???L?w?]0?EJ?R??'0P???B?­(??QNq???".??y?O???????K?u???f?#????B?mKX??@Y9??????d1????

7b??S?2=??(???b??V????9???s?Q?@??Zx?
??fR?qY??
‑?)?*??8??0,?4i?i?qN??q?Fv??????7.?-­&?,*????
!?L!@ft????OX??G??#?[1]4?????????@?

endstream

endobj

5 0 obj

<</Type/XObject/Subtype/Image/Width 468/Height 139/ColorSpace/DeviceRGB/BitsPerComponent 8/Filter/DCTDecode/Interpolate true/Length 9771>>

stream

????JFIF``??C






­‑ $.' ",#(7),01444­'9=82<.342??C


2!!22222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222222????

"[1]??­[1]

???[1][1]}[1]!1AQa"q2???#B??R??$3br?
%&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????­[1]

???[1][1][1]w[1]!1AQaq"2?B????#3R?br?
$4?%?&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
[1]???(??
??5?+@??N?}

?G????@9??r?~!A????R}Vu?Q‑???????|????????????7????t

?T?V)F????g+aaw{??q??'????h>?X?????]x?.???e???;???p?o???L?e"P???+?4_i‑"??F?

?????????????????}??s%??g+$g??=????qG??W??7???-???HuxW,????????[1]?;??`???~"?D??m???>?:?(?H????
???%s???E??v??:??V??????????W???‑??]?J?&?

???#­??*?MWW?????????????@:?*?f??(???????N4}<
?g???????u-
?????#???,??X??w
qQ??c?G?~????U????.q???d??=
?M_(|>?????Q?O$V?-??pcQ?}I?????0??\[frV?(?????^???F
?[?????"? ?r{??5?
?D??F??????x?[?????z??/7???b|?­\g??j?rw4QG?????x?Y:e?????Y?L?p??Z???­k'??-?5=?Hf‑g???o????@ ????%c'?? ????>?x?<?
??[?`??????^???=C??_?????L?/?????_0???c?M­C????????­????­???7?>z?????_<QS???????{xo?|??????^???=C??_???(???*>??????????????????#????,-o_-?-*??????k?~?????E??(}?????Rm??${?QZQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEKX?-?]"?R?8??3#{???x???­?????????}1g?G????T??Wg?k????5??R??Op?????Q?g???D??I????>????
*???5???????????c????L??a???????)(?>?t'?????6?­+??yx??,c­J?El?????><?K??3^?v?g??,#?b9????­?|?????
??G ?????]-t??z?F?b?????????]J??sV?u???????;?w
???~5?????<C?????Gs|g;OB?[1]?+???????\h?????‑???????U?h???????kV??o5[??v????n=[1]?$?_#?????\?W?y???a??W??{??;=3E?????a??/?[??
?o[V?­
2\N??????QTd?=??<

??K??"??`??Ta???tp???s?W?|?ST????

Ga??y?W???W?tAu?A??EUA?U[1]?????&???N?LG

?)??????:+B
o?~

??^??V?f?G/4??i:?c?q???IEW;??o???z???V-?z?c?c?9?+???????L?#o?Z?a??????*M?

+????)

+1C??

???G??:ez^???#?V????l7
q?G;?S??)?y?}_??Z???&?t??d????2???5??{_?Mk?h?7P?0??u??Z?=I???

cF????4?N???????e?#? ?[1]???T??????????h?,??q_??<

?@1??S?u?N?o???[@?"??H?rN1s?_e??‑"???U?????3Q4\Y?_Kh?
<w?i?3?????9??0?

?­??i???;?"???^p??[1]?!????*O?
?T??]o?>??1m-??f-b???????r??????????)?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??+???f_Y[g?-??1?_BW??????????L?*;?o^???>??\??v??????????­???|???A??????c?h????+????}???K1?3
???????_?y??
??b??????[1]n?^3???Y?G????W?|
~!??k)?N+8?[?g???q??x??(????????????[?n?I????I\ep[‑???@?

z???B?????????w?

??iq??3?_???{i???QEB
(??
???.?????N?[0??D^?S??H'????k???=??OR

?H???m???H??'&?o?p]G??O1.?$`?rN}Y?xu­???????

h???Q^??G????????m??I?d??E}QJ
@?>&?????????.??lF_&_M?6?? ?K??A??[???v????????"?zTl^??4V????H<?jE?I, H?_??Pkz?1
???_?3j???7??k?z???_?3j???7??j&\
??­???,?_????+???­???,?_????)@&iQE?EPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP_>|y?1x???­,??A?V9?b???.????????8?s??|?vG???Z?lTw>w?`?pZ?-??????[1]???????#??I??d%`?]?[?=?_?x??q????Q[|????I?;XA?+5???k?z?G?F?????K??4+ ?2:a_????Tw9J?o??f__?c???n}?????)?????e?K?M?

7?OtL???????c??2??????H???)???Z?k?~=??F??????m1?N???~??T??Gc??g???z??q"???­?^?_2| ???<s
s?K{?6??????

????HlD?
(?????(??=k?]????????a?8_???^]o??s?{?z??6?"????8?NO?\?c'vj????K?7?

??????ygAi???9?

?]o?/O????~??k?|??????????????E?Y?'?%?????/b?;?EF?T?q?=z??V5H`?[1]LN?T?t?{??]k??5-F??u? OUn? ~u?U????k???{?????iy???‑?_SV?z?j?????f???o?
????????f???o?
???f?????gJ??8?_W????gJ??8?J3J?(?
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
???[??u???o??3??"??@­­x???^??t??wD?G?!???+&9‑)H???
???W??????t??Xu6??????????5?S????j??[??7?????VR??S???
????vP???????+J?????>????I?+?????c;????u?????Q??????Z??i???M??P???!?=???x-??]]En???4?F}I?
??4?_???w?Mr?K?Re??["?c?}u????F?m????-?????;?????4I??r??r??;*{:?kH?'s'????|=y????????9V??N??]?????}???????#??2????-<gd&????
?)????_?????.???? ?A?s?'?kV??N?<????{?????r?z??kA??=|?z?????M??a???­J???h??>???>­??I
??2‑??(??bk?|+????1?N?

?~?????Us?r­Bx???$?$?M????\?m>??c????‑??x?Z‑‑????n??????*??W?F??jz?0i0M5??PB
T?????X????v???-Q?:?????NW??2s??'a8?x?%?$??I5????,?4???y????????k??

??i???????#B???????vS?‑??EV?E{?8?>??q????????????
?)?%?F???8??k???7?_?g?E??k:???????5E??r<R,??WBXut5?­?5d?|9??????U?;7F­?5??}?+Z?g?.??o??m??­'?B

????rZ‑?_x??FmW??&???}?_x??FmW??&???9?m}????t?????@??}????t?????@?4???????(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?Z????6??R?????l}=*????/?9x??{C.@????+??6F?
?p???%e?q??J)r??3??|>??K=????t?????=G?????wE?
:?V*FA??4?3???e??c??<???>??q?P???.???G?6??A/?ls?Z?IQ??????W?i??3s7??Y??W???#???+Z??????
??OnA??????Y@p$???*??U?o?&???Q?4??wH??#?g????u????6???­Q????????

F?
??^?Z-?3{??*?W?6???7P?????pz??/
^?=?????
?Q?05?P?av?!?t???^???????p?3_^?d?*???????G*
fg?:??[?]??????????{?>‑?.?/?[G?p?????­z???a\??Px/??????k????t?
??k???H?c???8?SZ?R??QE????h?+kv??
?nFC? 63??A[?P
?
???
????Z?‑?>??{?nt?W?YSc?+0#9?MttR??Ws???wS\??;K3??|?$?????v???????????[kx?-a??v?
,h3?0*Z)X.QE0
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??
(??$Q??%?]Ua?j?z>??dzu?????U?(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(??(?_x??????G5????v????I????{V?p7????????ZT?=??‑??&4iYx?:????h??<?d?g??G)­??O

?]ep­w?o?F??-???Cn?­?_???|Y?????O!?y?[~7c?q????????u??_????Y???m$?rU?p??Gl??+??\?????#?<@?&|???????a]??z.=???x?K?D?n?5

???x,U??b>T???

??xSQ?k?i??j??Q[??/?E?2T?P?8<?J.=‑??u????h?['????a?d?V???
?????]?????A?Q}J/I=?????HC??-+????z?h^??V1???????‑?oO??m??]?xR]???8?k???H????[F??uo"Nng2<G­s??
?>?wT???xyou??6'??y6??G?_?p
q??N?c????????k:Tw???m?E???cbH8??Z??4?SP?qw????Y?M??ke???]??{????????c???]koi? ?2?[?7?????1?9?KR??M^???,7?ZO?D??]A???q?`??<?I
????_E?]B????2
???NF@c?8?E??????gk-???)wv8
Rk?[?
?<??~?o??[k??}x­????S??{? I$I!­?.?????????@V?{`ubIo?4??`?r+?j0x?F?b???Z??$?w???????5???x???|g????N???K???p??Z???S?x6???‑?}q5?6RM!g;???O?#~??v=3??+?<.?{Xh?jf?R????‑??s???W^6???e??E???????Gl?????\?????FmF?]^????U?UO=?‑???S?????????T??=j???8?E?sz,B???G­???s?_7????E?????[???o?M0e???99>?=ESvW>?????????
J??o,?????2X8?;?o????g?????B?N?y?\9bYpA??pqK?P???/?d???o???Y??)??l??_?????|A??

Y?????0?????Y???|:?|]?k???0Af?L??W8

?‑???
?????????;??d???4??V?

????4??i0Rx?<?Z?????|?g??)H?T????

???^I?­V??O?Zf???,:V??C??v0;??K????>
??u???k?8u ?????Q??[C??k?9<)?k?b+t?xY??T???Z?u??R1yF??`9???f?}???}o?????/_L?p??!12??y???j?|_{?Y|;???~?sf??F0?T7??$??K?,{?P?????[??-^?X"gH#??Ga^2|=?Z|H‑????????1??8?9??????‑??H|??)5+???7-??!??|
r>?4??????]??­????t???F`al???pkz??S?W??z???\??+??0g?????<E?x{?~???W??k$?Y\??c+??o??`??V?+?.> ??u?Y???=?|s???9?^??W?Y_???}z?nex??S
!1?yQ‑p9??y???G>?t?/??G???o????z?_??
(??X??K??^??

??7??yH?????z
??+??i????4???L:?Q0?)??m6?
~I5{????<;???\?- ??`?&bG?R?g??G0X?z???

>?{???

d???(5?>0???????^??W??(
?[@^i??;???zqY‑???<
?}6?T????Kg??????‑??`??V?.??<#s?

"?{??I
q????=??

???I???+?9?&we??<?xa?

y???/??
?=v??s%??,~v#?i?2?????{?n­?????????Ap
?D?d?ws???
?????W??x?|K????s?????4????7?@??0??\?-???^j???<C??K|?p?8????|??}9yq?K+??-??ci6'V????1??e??

??c?O?????k????>??=3Q?]??
??????:???%?????ho?z?|F?&???m2?O!?Gr0??9??5C?~+?4o??U??5???.8??q??:???3?L????=?X??){??d )fe,8?*

~???‑1?F??{5?|??JzL??
????Qp??Z??K??????[A????,J?c?????W????'??gO????Sn??[6? C???*?@??m??h??W??FM???w???g t#??9???Q^?m[R?????!???i?"Yf
?/?9??k?B}V?????Xk7?w
?b??2X8?;??=???­??{????:??u=??E?[?2P?>~x??W?????????u?CW?a??d??=
s??G0r???????h?DvK0???ei1?n??z?a^1?{?/<W???b
?$r9

$?5???
(?????xj?T????&?+]gN-?<?Lr+
28????j(??Os?7?t???$

[1]?a4????4?????(>??j:?????/??ZJ???
??nB?
02
}Ew4R??q^???k?k??????k0?&[p?+(e?3?!H?j???x???
?i?z<?tD????????
??????h??s????;?gO??sk‑?iB?r??6?
??????l>#???????G?l??­

????v??E
?G?!???????E??<?+??yy???==?Z??Z}?tt??-??Xn???
??????E??i?k???Ew5?z????n?­??#'?'?^?o
???MmOF????I­??Yve[nA??O??}E
?n??x???w???6??{j?<v??tT??d|?I????xR??????????n[1]???‑c3
??????(?\?o??6???t??h??

6??[1]a?*????/
?????‑!?nt???K?????
,99???QE??

kH???{?.?K[?&??Q????5???????h?!???
­-?

?D'

i?$?=}+?h???gw??^???‑?????i??NZV?d???j??>???Yc?C<A?K?|??T?
\q???J?? ?8??‑

??e?????
+?5???

?U?x3[????x?E???n?)b?,>\2?`?X?8?A????h???xn?I?|?uA'?OQ?dW?\|.??????????????[t??????'?{?5pN???+U??u??=??]>%[??+;
???????<so????[?a????????z?h??.x??Y?+M*???:????r?a?Co8 ?????‑??z??????v?t?<??yl?T?zd[TP????u????O?u?c?i????n?
~j?$??????CQ'???????Y????o=?`?(d??[1]???­??*?9P]?*~x?=??P?Zq?‑O5C??H ???r??E?|=?5
?gK???'??L???[???n??H??T?????????R'??q?
D?0?0?Lc?Z???‑?Zv??
in???cR?L????:f?‑?,<?????7??O
??????????Y??|???;V???MCP?<#y????,??e???x?d??w?Qdg

?58~%j?'???!????qtq($c?????_?????h????Of???o?

?????r?,<???
?a?xR?????H?`T???
?????????kS???|Cuuc??%[?B?{?I?1??????,??????‑ ????,???-qa???r0:`??^?w?im?Xu;?G?Y?xA'?;?y?.~?+????.y??<??'???/.?????T?h??????????t­[1]Ke??
?SA,????J???O ‑
?]?Y?
?????????jRAsq~?eh?T?y?o??4?[1]x????N????2y
???2??m#?????(?
?t?.m??h/'[???
$??C??q????&?]??????[%????I
ol9n01??uE?#??
??|}???\[?????G-????????x??????4

j??? ??RB?????????????????V?>?<S?j????????*P??H­w=??.?O???e~????=?[1]U
I?

?I=+?h????w­
|m?xr?A??t??????????rI????Wg??/R?<?x?\??l#Q2???s?`?s??sE?.?[1]??????77p?Mf???FO??????oZ????­

???w?.???p[|??v?>?=??(?????­x

?????l?,F??F??]????'????W?A?????g??y?3?v9?{f???Ap??)???

endstream

endobj

6 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F1/BaseFont/Times#20New#20Roman/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 7 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 93/Widths 130 0 R>>

endobj

7 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Times#20New#20Roman/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 891/Descent -216/CapHeight 693/AvgWidth 401/MaxWidth 2568/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading 42/StemV 40/FontBBox[ -568 -216 2000 693] >>

endobj

8 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F2/BaseFont/Arial,Bold/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 9 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 121/Widths 131 0 R>>

endobj

9 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Arial,Bold/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 905/Descent -210/CapHeight 728/AvgWidth 479/MaxWidth 2628/FontWeight 700/XHeight 250/Leading 33/StemV 47/FontBBox[ -628 -210 2000 728] >>

endobj

10 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F3/BaseFont/Arial/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 11 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 121/Widths 132 0 R>>

endobj

11 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Arial/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 905/Descent -210/CapHeight 728/AvgWidth 441/MaxWidth 2665/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading 33/StemV 44/FontBBox[ -665 -210 2000 728] >>

endobj

12 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/TrueType/Name/F4/BaseFont/Arial,Italic/Encoding/WinAnsiEncoding/FontDescriptor 13 0 R/FirstChar 32/LastChar 121/Widths 133 0 R>>

endobj

13 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Arial,Italic/Flags 32/ItalicAngle -12/Ascent 905/Descent -208/CapHeight 728/AvgWidth 441/MaxWidth 1599/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading 33/StemV 44/FontBBox[ -517 -208 1082 728] >>

endobj

14 0 obj

<</Type/Page/Parent 2 0 R/Resources<</Font<</F1 6 0 R/F2 8 0 R/F3 10 0 R/F5 16 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 15 0 R/Group<</Type/Group/S/Transparency/CS/DeviceRGB>>/Tabs/S/StructParents 1>>

endobj

15 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 4107>>

stream

x???n?F?=@???@??r?Z?nSl?[1]]??>x? K??V?In???9g?G??mjI$???9????zw>.????????a?|?W????????????????a?8
??|^?|[???}s???w­??!E???Buu????D??'???i?G?????????(?~z??=&p?h?????R???_n??
?7??a???n????`????eh%?q?‑?T\?
??r??????????(?????UB%???P?Rv?_*V??+???/??q?g?#\O?
????F?.A?c??n?i????,??r????????d???0jD
B????1vE5#D??O?j&???
>??

/wC%J?????/??~??????~?1?g?o??_+B?????q?XV3j???HS
????‑?*k
u

n???????‑R??,??X?????O

??{Clv??UG9????g=????#n~I???m?
????w?????????'B?Y????~?t???
OaQX?>?$?5Z?I???os?0l???"~?c`m???@t??3?E????S???<Kc??w???g??‑4?K???uL?

?????d­==?????
?5????R??a???wR?6?#?
????k????<!???N??s??k?L??_9Hn?,?a??I?????8<???i?S??XM??d????????t???T\a???_?M????{Z!e?Y1?n?t'?]3I?V??+???6
h?????n#????(K? ip}??,s?rE??^[b?=??yv?m???u?w?‑8??j?<\W????e ??e??3?
?Pnv+??W?e?8nKdv??1ji0F ??5[1]?]??????}???????w?zz????m?k??<??%b????Y???‑??????N?}?-???(?Y???uD??????a???????9??????????xkU ]
kv?\?? ?'Y?????!@???H_?????<OE?O`?g;????{?-?^N?j????5"]??2?????'?9??pN??u?^?%C/??a?pN??\?{??K??$??c??x?:A?s?2r
k?Upv?H???7????n??c?0?y???7

??????K???i??????[?'?­???=??j?E???9?9??Nh?????I[7m
???Z
{y{???/?pxo|?y?$?????
R?Og8?D,?D'
?/wn?h????k?C??V9D?[?
?!???f???7???Gc????|/??mo­?7|?F?`??

??x
UK??W­z????< ?t??}?j?G?q!??O??q????^??0???Z???9???s
?|?n????J?G??[?Gb?X?L????7"?G+

KQ??|????)?Iq???+5ecq}8+?????5
?/???B+??ez????*M>???{

??
??r?O?b???E?????????????b????P??uq?H3v??3L???
????h?H?-Bx?C?G?09q ]S?,???8?K?A?????<)

M??m:?u?J?(‑4?

+0l,?

6?u???=?B7,Tc???.?????Nk??1?????????`,?[2?
'%z!\?'?hR????$??r?K$PE????‑?}???{m?>W6tv???}6?TM?D??I1?????9?:?sV'v?????????HA?mzFS4]2??????d?
Z?.]'[??&,???>H????OE??~
!W??d]?6‑???9bn{)s5??]J??????LF@G??+?*K??9I?sTy???z????B???GH?‑??j?V?W9?(Y?.?^6?v??&?{0?w$&????;<c[*S|???????}aD?D‑???[1]_?Z????"?????W'?:u
????&?M?^??&?n|???_?????G"H???w(4?E%'?V^:W}??F???%??hB????G!'G??5T??r5?
.?????D???]?????????L&:?]???/@?8%??????h??=?;|j3??L"?)?"?n?}(???T???q
X&????pz?P?e??3???????H??\x?Q??[1]????u>:??lYpG?C??0,_?t#vc?+FY?O?Z?{[?s?Y???}R"??uO&p?r??????,?u??0?4:T????%_" y
G9???X,?&8\>A??p2?+??mp???#vwf???u??D?k?????t?E?tV9?

??"?I?1?3????1OI/?????Sp7????C%/??0?,rGH????QQ
`Z1?\3?#o?
??{???1?4??

?.????u?????4??*L?M??)N?(09? )
?tU

???JG??gWI???^???%]??{??u????D???[1];=!Za
????6??'8ec`?j>?]d?4?y???iF???$aN ?v­??%??T?Q_?R?'DN
?Q#x?S???$-?‑Y???1f??`???(??
E???'v1???Q???<#?????%?KX?u=8???????F??<F"?Kb'???(g?????yU~v???o???zgt????i?@H?0y?WT????????[1]???\?0?(#???
????????Z?

??B(?At?'??bi?+???m????Y?n???????-. @sh<‑F ?*???{>?n????[1]????Nf???*y?a??5YD2??N??o4?}??v>S??1?"e?@

??Es???
??3????>@I????+?

??S?9???s??z*[1]?*9???

??D)??mP??*4?4j??

"-??>f?7 ??ae??????hM?_??y­f#D?J??L<^?'?????"?????e<?????"qE3­????#???Q???T4???'\ zY
P??>?tq???$????[;??­?]T
Y?????5GI DH??@?N

X?
???)?

??
%????????:)?z???5~?h??+=?e?+?&?-;N??????s3O$Gv>{?*>?@'?8???)&????x?

????g?2?3?*?K&g??"?????‑??{??D}

??

?

?????~???U?Hl7}%Bk({?)?]0?K;­???‑­A?1:?‑?Xl???L?
??
???G?2?9?FI?\y?!I?
c?????1?q?F?]?Ms??W?M?vO­<??Mk-???

???Gf??????<!%?P??4m??Nu8@?2^{???W???\E?
????0.?Z???????4???#???Dh8

?L???w?gQt AH?Q??5?OD?W%????|p??-W?X???rl?

2? ?‑(????,?|&

?c?O???kf?????m %&l?????????s??
?V????????a?
???H?cqn+??4'?p_?z*O????????????%:?? ?a&????VrX
?<P???&
8^???‑?‑??T~???u?%?d5?b??????????b?/???q?sJk?S8?x4Q?#R?|2VK?l?V)??<NE~H?/F??X1??IH??i?+"rL????$d?#U???R?f?4k?????YS7?~?
V???Q?]??????W??????{Z?e?+e??&?;??? ?&????/­e?Y?I?????k??d??M?h???????6?E@?d?p?-('?`)e??R?^??[B0`???,{?Ds?fh&??????qX?+??9??/?X
7CDgC>@,?iX??A??B?2???{&x"T??1'*

?n???ye???J+@DM{U'?????:????v?k|/?%???p(N3?t?EEZ|??????yG??????T??]?^???Gx???Y?a????3?",p?A?????D???(2
?Io?o1?.V?w 9?R??t-0z-z

m|??%z?>9>?M?G?z:??????WY??;?J??f^?_???A?cr??d???

UwL)??|G??~??^??R8?????J?#8???^RM???j%?)??F???­?/Z?1??
?1y5?R??Ew3^?P/???????D?0?????/??&???g??|^???G????????9??3=??-?9??3?"E`??m??"?Hk?KQu???R?j??x??J??B&?7

endstream

endobj

16 0 obj

<</Type/Font/Subtype/Type0/BaseFont/Arial/Encoding/Identity-H/DescendantFonts 17 0 R/ToUnicode 134 0 R>>

endobj

17 0 obj

[ 18 0 R]

endobj

18 0 obj

<</BaseFont/Arial/Subtype/CIDFontType2/Type/Font/CIDToGIDMap/Identity/DW 1000/CIDSystemInfo 19 0 R/FontDescriptor 20 0 R/W 136 0 R>>

endobj

19 0 obj

<</Ordering(Identity) /Registry(Adobe) /Supplement 0>>

endobj

20 0 obj

<</Type/FontDescriptor/FontName/Arial/Flags 32/ItalicAngle 0/Ascent 905/Descent -210/CapHeight 728/AvgWidth 441/MaxWidth 2665/FontWeight 400/XHeight 250/Leading 33/StemV 44/FontBBox[ -665 -210 2000 728] /FontFile2 135 0 R>>

endobj

21 0 obj

<</Type/Page/Parent 2 0 R/Resources<</Font<</F1 6 0 R/F3 10 0 R/F5 16 0 R/F4 12 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 22 0 R/Group<</Type/Group/S/Transparency/CS/DeviceRGB>>/Tabs/S/StructParents 2>>

endobj

22 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 4926>>

stream

x??\[s???~???x$S??[1]8v?J?Z?:v?9gSy???")?D*?h????e? AR?c?)b0??????{???????L7???^\m6???|V|???|???????????n1?t???eq??????????(?,>??'?
?E??m???5e

o????????????b?K????????H???m]??????tS\
0y??l??????h?N?B5???M?X??K??
K?????O7­??????C1?/???>????R?*?-j??M??????h?­?X??-Lx.??????f?+????f????3~v
?<K??7*??*??VUSX??E?eY?b5??­*,[1]d?)A?)?R

?mQ[]zq????z
???U??[1]?FAN???A30???|?????<??[%???@XT??c???c??I??:-_A??
H?(G?????%???:W1??XTL?i??hR0=??T{????????[?6ee?d_?B???}?)?

R?uv?[1]t????nz*h?ca?k'?6??+R?o??_?

?=?|[1]??|U
????:g????a?E?Y_?J
?S????????_z????CE???lh_?\4????4 x;?P?$!P?G?CB?NQ?$?'h|??????R?h?D­??us=?N???I-??k?5(?i??m

?[1]ZNA?????U?s????L???V??G_:?

?L????V]???c??M??????{????*??Z0???Z??l(?([*?s??r?W9?8-?a?V???J__??????????T?x???XO:????Rc???1??\?n\M??]wO?^?*??&2??????~K?B;1b??9k7??d

??{i???
#???????????P?%???
?]]???j????b????kK[1]8w:?Cm+J??<??q?v?r???s?e71H????d?8b?h?q??aS?%-???j?-??z???5?yz??#S???-1
?_??7???<E???B???&A/?`?????y??Ou/??.??
?PU?k?f?q6??????9?"??!­C?@h?u2w"???hD?&???7`{??????k?=k?n????.?k???M??i;?B71???lf??b??RNT2Gu?:????"?!????&{X??#?s?4?0??K!????+??bu???9???BL?O??I?6y?2?0?5
?????4T??u??>??7??;?F­?sD1G?&?[1]???X???Z???S?(?????l????xLT
??0?p­??<??I?q??E???+o??w|??#?t[s?9l???)??J@??v?DA?y0?XSV?TuN? ??o???_D???`?l??X3?[1]>?????+c??B?:t???8]-C??Q???9?%???[Ag?%k|?4?v??H?[8?&l,???????=?~?L‑&e:??D??l[?^d'?h?s????PT"$?~7?k??}%v ?\????~u2???????$?6???Nb9?^? ??A 9@??Gt?p?^&??C???+??-j:0R
GDgZ?????4`??????‑?Z?D???!?@?#?t??@?????????v???
?/c­:BR??h]???"?
??f?]????
?^?_`?1????-???~‑=?O?\?Q>zs???1?l??fb??I']`?Dd????dcs????6???Kk??? 2H?_???;??MoL?S?sG????^???dP?a?\"

$t??,?????M
?j??p???a:b-?,????Y
?????T5f‑+8???7?m??I‑?}???

=}o???v
ry#8"e

‑tf??H?-?a??O+ ??m??L?/
?????r

I?g?|???|???)w?J[1]'ogk:c????|3?n!I???c?|???q???[?????<*kUj????rT??Y?W???QI??S?^???vO?? ?3?k?+?y??7>k
M­kynJEx?,'????U????Z?a!g?&'???-?,4???
m?2TG?<?V=S???#*q?
?*????[1]??t?Z[?:?#?m??]w?q}??X#$?u?w?b??? ?M?e.??S?^[1]vH??)L??e??4???@>??\??u?#"????c?88??????6?­X?PJ?#Je???z?

?l??TIq??[1]??g?x????O??M
?Y?f?^>

7??>=?g?O???+h1j1
?????

?]????

_?G?\?6?ja/@??????|5?Zc?d@­J???|??~q?
p ????$X??Q?=W???J?g?c?
?{?9‑???R???O???w>?2??I?

&+????I‑m????v????
?;G?6????9AG????q?<????1gP8T?B?$?‑W??v+?N????_?0?????j???????)MS?F??=z7???;???XC}8i??m6?C???~g{4????<w$?~??V????fI?|?)???????l?????oH7?{???@z????WvU,g???h??Fc?(#???U???=
?ls?&@[?v??m??
??C????@-?w)&?qQP?
?????‑?)????B???*+????65??O9??Q?&/??d^?po~??
q?????H??w~ZD?h??:b?
??????+???_?#UhG?5?*?s3?`?v?VT3????Asd!???
(
???

???????

7??#??[1]?d?A???o?5rU??????W??u<?G??­?????P????I07???6?Z??P?2???0?eOp?d??tB?D?X??irD@G???b?­???n?~??????{\?'XL??RQ2<???_???a?G?q?V????a Qu?????z?:l?B? R??d["6??)?

?7????u???????? ??C???M[1]??????;

??l??zZ????i??`?M6?????V?}g[6X??<?????dA??+g3??`?
?Lf???G???v#??W>

?"9

????Mh????
|v?$
_??lMD>­?hb&?*???????Z??Ui?$??U?5?­9t?
=??e~,??'1Ucz?E|???\
??$`*?s?z???8??1??G??????nU<???:]Q2?Jc??Tr
K?_??.??z??/

/W%l;??

?u????B\??Y<????!C
T???
?(??'??q6??nr? ??X????>??sRBh5u??????`?P??\??E??
?[?????O+??<????"C??a????.?k??.?{N7???[???mE?J?3?n?q???>i9&?]e?N8b6?
g'W?;?R?$?G?O?$???‑??
??4i5???g8???????D??X???4??u!?h??>??~;?.h??u?????????Y?E???#­???K/???T~???:?????0-;x?/<???
/?^?P?>?Lu??$???w?1??R????Ki|?O?
­C????k|?
?­?m???#B?{??
qj?Jr?Gn?r??i?????U?y|??a=? \??8??}???????
???2­?X?K!????????':?Z???k???ASY????e04N
ES??^??v????6????|??'
@?CUJ[?Li?r???^Ue??E?????M??$i????,1???????a??[1]??H?}%?DI???jt
?D??B8?_7o??em???|?~???=??

?/??%We?mm!‑??W?9??_0?[1]???n????FS??`?]k[1]+???s
??K.?k?O3??&???q?­9?~@?S?4????? %??=A=U??"?T?R-%??,?
?7?X?E‑???i?
??w8??p??+.50E4????????H?NW?

w
P:??9????^?4?Z?/`8ld?]l??_???w?G??V?d?4p??R2^?]?/????

?W;[1]???lz[1]??^?d@?

?P??"
W????jR??91??i?.?m?:­???>???^????6??n????E?X??b???7?????%E?#?&)|M?
b

??9V?
?e??????p?3?u8????O????]?1?w?_?.???a??? ?xD^??q]b?‑?i?­?????v?$Hk?CA?U????

~
?i??8??6???^?z?`??p??*????hB???j~??????C(?*??G
??Vaq$?{p?m????;???
??????!???[1]%?????
^??j/?<}A??
??Qh?????mC,??????'2{Dx?0?­??-??M?x??.??M$??O0?????1??H?8??H_,`?f??)?|????#??|????B]
9C????????

‑?^?6???.???gT???(???)Y??`??:?RF`???i???'[1][1]??O?E??=!m?`???$?'ga??W?^s????t')??U?WV0]?+m??lpl?JY?ccI?[1]???'??1??
Vg????Ph????­??‑?????#???R??B?????.?^??3[5e??7??3??`??=??????????^)????[?=??O;?a?-??)?s?{?h?M5???1??5??n~?_?
????????j|??:????&?Iy??-?9_)??3b?????X????????.???VF?Jd]???"? ?g???VJ[???0?<P}-^??1!????G?v)Kt?t ?}8???
????#i???_??5a

:YF???kmU6??­?<2?k

.?D_;????e?n‑'??????-?*

?*b(?????S??K<?
???
?????7?

'V0RAuY?S?W0??$5+?bmhP<???[1]????

5?f?
?:Q??‑Ps6?
:[1]
b6'=t$R:??­?(5V-?"???^?O?xN??Ih/ ?x?3?=?Z?by???\?

7?????{%^?i?m????~???BW!?U?;?? ??~@?'Y?n???0?>[1]????

endstream

endobj

23 0 obj

<</Title(CITATION:)/Author(hamiltonrx)/Creator(??Microsoft? Office Word 2007)/CreationDate(D:20110805123126) /ModDate(D:20110805123126) /Producer(??Microsoft? Office Word 2007)>>

endobj

29 0 obj

<</Type/ObjStm/N 105/First 841/Filter/FlateDecode/Length 1273>>

stream

x??X??7}7?­?FU???S?Y??????/?7l??}Nui?????a???>:u;jI-?y?E??2.<??M"
I????D?<?($?*P???R?w??D?SH??Rt?K?
?R()$S[1]$?;?????)

=@?PI^?:?-T?<D?
E??0:"DW??????bd??,[1]?[1]??c&????(??W??/ ??)???.Q???|??\(c\??paD??T??f$??'?LYk?Re??e?U??­,p?
B?L??8??????P???S
lMT*??NT?8?k?.P?8?. e?p?$0*`1????????[1]?$??[1]??C)$
??'kQ??U???????Huy?????[E*?_?C??\l??????E????az??E?NB{?%???????{m?9 ??<`

FI?p\h??02??+FU???g?G ?AG!?\t
?R????![ ?=t+?%‑dU
2

??zu??a??O?Nw?7??{O??O?????_??@x?~?)D??'?@???[1]????p?C.?[1]?7???y??????~?oC?Y?g?A??$N#?]*????s?.X?????l‑?????)$??[????p??<???????G???k??~?t??d?

?8??E?V?=??k???l‑0??<`??4?
3?"?t%J?(???t2?d??????/6??z?CQ
????3?Q

f:S?T?=F?B?????*R/?|X???
??g?L?3:??w>\8R??,??i??iq??T?f???
Y?,?C????G??i?K?Z/?KD??????6d?L2`?

0??
?iC?[1]lz?M??jr?lF?????2?[?[kb/?ih??p??p??Z??0????=Aa?.??nO??=G

?J???W@?[1]?+??[1]?+??[1]?+??[1]?Ss??????????????aw??gz???‑"??Ds?<B????t*?

??_??????&&?8?+??
HvAW?;??[1]??Z????D?­?6c??h??h/???$??%$$$5??d{??Y?g?=?E?X??(?H?R?­K6c,?X??Tc????I?r???o66?????f7‑n<?x???
????m<??K'm??q??I?C???
??a???Z?‑??y>??<}?xyx:??1yNw­????[26?w]g???o?_????o\o???&1]]m?O?J?(??~?C?'??L?T?
??l????????s%???gV

e{?~????e?w+?_??I????xUa?9?J??H?????????

endstream

endobj

130 0 obj

[ 250 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 333 0 333]

endobj

131 0 obj

[ 278 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 333 333 0 584 278 0 278 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 333 0 0 0 0 0 0 722 722 722 722 667 611 778 722 278 0 0 611 833 722 778 667 0 722 667 611 722 667 944 0 667 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 611 556 611 556 333 611 611 278 0 0 278 889 611 611 611 0 389 556 333 611 556 0 0 556]

endobj

132 0 obj

[ 278 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 333 333 0 0 278 333 278 0 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 0 0 0 556 0 667 667 722 0 0 611 778 722 278 500 667 556 833 722 778 667 778 722 667 611 0 0 944 0 0 0 278 0 278 0 0 0 556 556 500 556 556 278 556 556 222 222 500 222 833 556 556 556 556 333 500 278 556 500 722 500 500]

endobj

133 0 obj

[ 278 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 333 333 0 0 0 0 278 0 556 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 667 0 722 722 0 611 0 0 0 500 0 0 0 0 0 667 778 0 0 611 0 0 944 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 556 556 500 556 556 0 556 556 222 0 0 222 833 556 556 0 0 333 500 278 556 500 0 500 500]

endobj

134 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 300>>

stream

x?]??j?0
?????.J?Z
!??+?b??R[?
?c?"o?G?:?????/????96?

???Q?xo??0?7??_?j,??k????????$??y
04?­YY??#??g????[1]O,y???W?:?m????7
`????>z??k7OP?nt??0???/?sv?SdIf??ar?[1]??+?R?S??O?????.???<fg1[?TTH'?IJ?g?4G?%??(#??vH? :m???hO?Eww­????O??? w?Y?H??)>‑(???I???u??2?eO?????q??L??2Kc??o7?E??­?t??

endstream

endobj

135 0 obj

<</Filter/FlateDecode/Length 27851/Length1 95380>>

stream

x??}|E??????????L2=L2@BH?D29#H?
?$@$???[?*???eW?u?I?l@]Xa???U9?5??I???ga???(???o?u?????????B?anq???g??­??h??+G?????<­??????
?>???@??[1]??vfEe???? ??Q?pVe??;n?@t‑???1?????[1]??P^tV??+?aybz????U????w}?v???5sw??
???t???
??o,

???i??w??W/??[1]??!?/?QS??A??M???^v?wLx`?????M?}?<e?
???w?????????[??+Y?u?a?wa???u?\?????c?????v?E?:~?
??d\8gZMqS?H?c??]s?\#?P?‑?/]T3?v?????
‑g?;?~??
+??<??;?v???????1????8XQ|?k?7?80???o2
7?????k??Ag??^?g?P;??l(????‑:4A??M#dU2(??
Pc?z?2??d9?*!?q??{??v?@??2??/i??7z?Es?
??\????$S;?4{???R?&?
????$???`??d?9??%|???:7uNk‑?;?,~/
<??
1'S?_g?\??X?a)J??a!??[1],%/???‑C??_??Q?Y???,F}>???y?b<?G???u2~??>??+PF?yi@????Q?B?
*T???7[{?B???W*T??I?7?PDP?M*T??B??%?<~,C??/?&%?rq k??
?g?????"+???9????&?????oo

???????U??ANlr
?*Nez??

p????>-|f?
??d??Nn=??#`???&0!???lQ?
d??6???
6?0?#?Cr?O??Q???#?@?c!?q??P8‑???!?N?%?Gv??H?n??!\?I?????7r?HD?‑?d?S???-
?~??
?A2r:? ?T?A??@?!gB:?`(

C‑
??? 9?_A???0

y??y0?
?B‑
????#^?E.?a????\????%0????0[1]??#?y"??p!?????T>g+<F ??H??0J??)\g"WB???a4???????`????y"r?
c1>*?'C%?y
O????& ??9?S?????<&"??????$? ?P?
&#????0
?1~??B

?l????4?9
????~????ar??
?N??A3??,?K???K?[1]??`6??p?
_s?????W?<y­\?p

?#/??????p-,D?N??p????K???e?K?r??
y74???7?U?s?n??F??A^???#??[?O???????u?N?C???b???/??w"???p?*h?????F???M?w+|??|/,C^

???C???[?­???­???­?;??a???ox

V ??? ???cp'????op?
?E^
w#??‑?&???E^??[?~?}x
‑????
?‑Dn???7???~? ???????????#o??!??@~
?D?[1]k?w`+???M?????/@3???N~
^????)?W`=???w?m???l@???
???:<??<+?o"?o?????M???f?uxW???9??a
????
?B??G?^?w?N?w?K?v?

/#??W??*?^E?

?!
?!???kp@???:??

y??D?L?6x
?sxG~
?????[1]?C??G?
>@?Z?o?C??>B?
>F?‑?e?v"???????+|

??/A;?C??duL?????|L??I??eL???1??????1?zc???1}?qc??_??*c??_??{?1}O?1}?2??Q??=??????w)c?.eL??;????1?-uLW??????{_??~??_[??c?:?w=????G\??d?????>????7???????q8
??P*PF??p?#!?Szb+*?@7zN???8EcdO???w?????????\??????1v????????N??Z-?????n???.?T??$???H:/N;PStO???w?k`C??
‑?_@?i.
?@8?;?Ze.?‑??x???!ZX?s??SF7z?:?v????vAE??5??C{???_??[1]3P??''k?^???tl.2cLi????A??T?"??s
'6Qq?????vAE??(?Nb.2?,a?q?n???H?????^?s:??????E|N?PqP??‑??vAE??????Ns?]|?st.b?cs??C?gp:bsFA???8?C??F??E*N??9???8IP[??vAE?F???sQ???????`QBf???)?Co0?F????z^?(h
?A??Rh??j??H?)?=?:/N;?0OO???w#"YdOd­??@b??3S???:?????F?Ic4
???&#hqf2Z

!ZXj?????8Etc.2??D?I??H?iT?nD???????.?????\????
??b?????1i?-f
?LZ??f
??R?S?"??n???MT?$???=?????????)?c???d?CxP?1

??
??j?Z?V?Fc?DZ?V?[tVs?????P?E???n???MT?$???=???????H??:}???\?<??2E??ci??Uu???Z?1?(?????}?a?/:????='??&*N||nO???wC?F?mF??u???z"?3S???:?:?6?h?lv?V???m60?z?5??9?!{Z\?­‑??9?????/y{????????"!:?????F??C?6;n????
F????\????='??&*N????]P???t?
??w3t??_Lpbs?3??7J?‑?
??7DDh?aZgDD???[?-D­??L:??YT???s?_P?? $???.???H??ph???????*????????};?QQQQ??(?!???pSTT|d??K??\R??G7zN\??8? $W??
*z7?&??l?4??z??.%dsQR ???v?cc?bc-??C??
?(sl?+*??E??Z

????85t???????
??I=???????‑???eX???]?T[1]?d9q?
???pX
?!????p?-???qG???i????<??SC7?")dN?~?dL?iT?n
????ft?^???~??7?

H

d???????fs?95>!?q?????!???n7????????U??
j??C/?iT?n?.???E
???????n??E??,?Q:???$?K?(Ifs?y?$I/J??!????B?????<???I
????
z??E?g???????u??_*

*?[1]Y??=????')),)?j?c?IJJ??>aI?t??##C?????<??[ )?????????vAE?F??l?????ADWoUd

??c?3[1]Y??o?>9?????l?yl??????HN???eLL??W???x??C??i}???vAE?F???!*??3Q???oY?T[1]????????????4{X?}DZZ8????K??
?=4%??????!?????????vAE????`aw ????g??c???P
???????????????333????Z?????p??YT???#s?B??i????vAE?????=??G????@?
*;???L??gggdg?geGFfDVfgg?+??=h??A?q????<??
]??_{C?????{??‑\P@?t
?0F6[1]w[1]{?U?
?4(??i??J8??e?Z??b????
?????????M??`6??.?i??w???/???>?D??"??5?C??O??]}2??????@V???KJG?uf?Y??‑S>v\??pN?o????;{\0\????n??k???h|e?7?y?rs???
??40=-u@Jr?~}=I??>.????????????D??l2?:?F?9J`@???Z?{????=rd*K?k0??SF?_????m?R?b&o?E???????vXQ????R?[?o+vK?d??*??\??I?6%>Z?/W?f??\??T]W,?I?T?/]X?XR]??5

E??ZC?h21j????=??D

'J?F??6Q???)????­?.f‑?????????U%?q.?/u??MsO????oMQL?H???)?k?j???h?F?i????ZE?Z?b???^3?????X????­u???cI,?^T???6?k,??)?dc???zlUg?????e??4????????B???b_??,?*%v$??[1]?W?.a9??$??]??k?U??&???.s5??z7?? ?Dj??r???qn_M??)?]?.?????M?-??Mk0b2w??v???b?be?:Z?0????C??izR??c?fT?

????
?#??:???~}Qu??????~!ItK???w?g???

s4I?7????tt5?­??SR?????h??????????
[??=W?0???rl?_n:6???N???^?????@Z??q??MO??i5?l>???4

G5?W??'?(y?_??????a%u?~??P??e????????`??U‑?
??;t???????????-v?I?,Qe??I??Q:??V?
{??C?R?X=2?>??u?;????^Jpl??????????K­????C?y-????h8N?]-P??`?=‑*?\R?­????????l&?8????`?
d????>

???Jq?kl,uK????5?r?T?$?7???s?sK??v?Vy??q???|?Vu$/

?Mn?tl??,??X?A??bieU3%?????????


?J.e?,?%$??2??Lu?}?/@????
%=?????;?G`Z+

??G?(???<???????????G?$}?M???>\B?Q8p"???A???
?^

X?9sP?A??rX?x????2????

?f]??$k[1]?I????s|?p??@X<*`?048??V?
??????
"?H??Ba.2?[?J8a5~?i?9^??.??q?&\??r??S???f?-??@ez????????????2?-8????(?P8???t7\Cwa????(??lB??rECw??????`?­A:J>??{Q6?B????E?!
f?|J?D??????l?­`????fsVN?%??‑?8?????`?‑??J?h??????]'?8W
?o?­?y?"??R?R?2E??w0?
4?,GY??G??"??"??Q^Ey?xQ?QttG3V?J?7{
???5?[1]Da?n?/*???y%|??K_?0?????N(0?‑p­C?t?
????N??F7a?8??Q?Q??LAY????h???N;?4???l??J?0???,??S?}Lb??=cH?J?z???b%&yn?

c?<???1F??a?????c??>
c?<?`??gL%??Z?=O???s?
??l?K??.?V?

xz????vWsr2??*oJ?dg?F??
iG?'

???j???4????HC
ip??

??%

O?ll??m9.???&

/??'HC=i???$??H$??m???Q?JP?

?
?u???3???
[???????&??(??????'`???>???????9#??q
??-??????,d
`E?G???????A?>??2????(?(SP?A9??Q?9?BaN????c?A?????[­?\???b?8?[? ?2&AN?Y?|?f??l????;????A_????e?'by0\??C??????y?YA?[1]<?:?‑??a6?+?!???p08??f4;&?n?f??Fba{?w????<?h?=?x??????f?????z?[??/???0?O+?`???npd;?xY1]??U???Y??y?c??[1]???

(???????????;?:??X?zg??<g^?j?g?s ???&???J??

???Y???;@?B[?????
???Nm?6N???D?Eg?t:?F???
t???.o
?G
??,???y%.R??v??kDG?L??qe??????7O??????
w+1??/?
??^e??????V?<???R????[?D?->????8?UV??e-?c+?

@?m??q,???f??#?G????rJ???? ?C?q?x????*?c?>????2??l)??|I
?o _??W??N?,?????>_Y+????D?@;?1_(v?

??H??????]??v?,@;?‑??$?^???k?O,)nJLTl?$?Wl????6/'?MR?b?/+6/G60?p???@??bBb???8H?b2??Iz???
???8r???1?:jc??6)'?????n?o?$vS?.?E?????.??0U??????7?????XXS???k?????R??I]?'1?0wqL*??j???-n‑?V??)??Q>8???n??kpy??????Fdu??b???,VW?k?w?R(}???I?>\5+?:j4`??s?
#?????;?}u?F\??#?D??????T??L??SY??jP}?0W?F?&?1??.???_
?%3???Zp1k????PW?????
???e?|\­6i??[?
??{4?h,??r 3

3sY&?u??<???

y?/
?E?*h?O?#?

??}??????PP?)???%6=????I
??Z??6?????,?8
???`?
w???`??F?A?‑???~?X??r???3?L?B?­?Z?[1]?? 3???????Z?-?<??W???%8?M??`n[1]??Ab?H??p????9p5l?H-­?k`1?&????
?????,?b?;?k!
???`.i???[????!???(­#??4????
??­B*??gX;?m?????4???0­Vq?y"??D\p???h?F6?,???hr%W??< ???h???P?`#BFP?0I‑-o?H??R,u%4?z?Z?Y????????a??0
??^#???#???????h?9????`q??9?I?????[
?`<z???)??^??5??|?\l?[Yk??`7?%?d
?@??9?‑n>???A?M????wb?­c?YOMt;??8??&?}?l?3????n?'1??J?????C??":??E?pw???ohk?????p3<
?;?&c????\I??[?J??? h???C\7?{?/???????n?h?j???z?wr?|=??????3??G???????=D Fb?M".2?\????fr?YC‑%-X?
??????y?jh.u???M??z?
?W???3????R?!\‑????WK???=???c??????!????
??5&??pF???$­??????hono?wC?C?+?
*???m?????????mK??pr??2??#?bK^GV????$?`+?K
??f?P|N?Ch!??y??????m???C?????r\27????r
?????{?????}?????x'????)?~
1???/L^>?4?5?kZ5_?f??\;V;Y?L?^???{?x
???3V??[??pO?-4???????O???h?=??!K?U??&
?j??a?l8?{??????o?0n4)#0??,????a??o?6?<????K5&r5=?1A3??r??q?????I??}?o?@?H}?+?^?,?\?[1]?Wx??G???h??'?M???&???PI2????????eq{?Z???mx/?????
?2???­‑????p?&YA^?3?FFZ???????D??p??????????7????????In4XG??
?
??y?"?L??? 3?# ??????\???U&???‑???8
p?1'{?Y?/???
?;q?????k??^?M%m????????>
&??Jy\$??8‑,?????'?
????W?\?q|­????R?](?Si#}?V???_l?$

???IL
??F?]??|?&?m???p?]Sqy???s?a$?2???Mr)7?w'??­???u??0????[1]?hSp]?
f[1]??A
???lIH???%n??^~[1]????W??'?p@W5i??0??V??k??i
?\>O?KH??#? ????qM
E?A-???
????<?F;.?R????`\???N\??-~=9o??&??"???C~?h?????]'???yb??7h`g??q?????Y;???\??II????~??ml??X???Z?
p?S<??5????Q*%??a[1]4???1x???s??l??9?n|?Ol?? ?1zt????9?fb??m??C??o+?'#g(?m??=?cj??z7b?K?^
????U?(|-??Q??W??v??6,:P??m?g?s­>l_-X????b?x?*??|?b6kX?k??d????


??

??:}???[.?$<??,‑?:??K?Xg??_??2e??&??[8?A/???l?i?Z?u8?bg?j?V???Ik
G?8???8?7??^?A?%h8M+?????t?K??O??k7IP?????@????????4????Y???-7K?V?v-?F??????????????n?bc??6????m?????G?!-%?*q???h%d'%????D????u?!
?whF\?%?*???r:?F??A?>?#??M
???$??9??<}5Z?f?N?>z??]??O?XY???)l???<?^L'?.??F?????

?7?f?????Y????Z?F?xl??),&A?y^?
??????Jx?{???k1?`??????Y????x.Y??????#?????S'\??F?*n?e?c

y????m??&V
cy?­7???:7{S???V |\X???K????z&x?u???H:?31ot1?&E?
,e?????

?n??u??6[vk??2y?<?V!?I??w?I?C?33?(????????????|?sg?o??????????>$?m?|??G?N??????t????I.z?2?i?+??o?????O?­l|???&?E??9x?)BAG<?u?g
V????0u` ?????[1]a|B ??UBo?Y,???[1]?I?y??5?>????$9
?]????)?F??u??????Z?V%?y???*?=_9????????(?q?????{?o???#??.?q??????M?????x'??V<F??k?l??:,????Y?6?b?J1?n}???b&;S
V?Buz?tzj0j??F?yhl?\???":?iK?8??z??#?????y??c?f?=*'%E9?)??N?r??9?y??u8?x?,F?‑?i?8C-?F‑??????

N??$???
&
??:?v??4%??4?vl?^3(?R-;????F??????[1]39p4?['???????i??_h???"6?i?i????'?X??s???K-K?:#t9???1??+?zu?????t%?B?B??{D??S???????k??????3?If??$d"??08???y
`-?<T??XQ?U?UE{?X?????-[1]?knK????jo?z????Rn??????h??~??9g?3g?c?????Z{?M<??<#i???K?)i3???#T'I???? +??Bg??8{????G??SR‑?)???<??{?CX%?0=? e?????V3????_?e??i?M|.
??????}
$?????[1]aD?

??1????o??HV#??W

??O­|??w(?M???gu??=H­??vC??4????]?3*rzi????6??u?{V???
????@???B?B(<?

W?U6I???D??o
E[???_??m`.?????O?????????[???S

)MD+???NO??r?%???rs???­7?R?i$???wa
??U??KE????"?g??K`????F????At‑????W?????=??­?D?OkE??f[1]e?]q^???O?

?+?????m

???
C5?0?&?C#??322M?'9"s???\????Y?l2E??X8??|V???&/?/?????????j????'
?aLF"???y??h??{?,G?Q%?W???a??p?`(?{?;IZ????????%9?xZ??ExI*F?`0?h?\‑tH??5?LY?kY?#kR$????!???F,??eI"???8?;?b?p?#?(?4?
???x<cw
[1]O4?????4?6?XtJ?q??X??2u???­Cw??q^???x?M???????1?F?y???+??.?o???m??;%BX?w?4?YO‑?@i‑??S?x?D?%^U??-??-??[1]D­`??d???<RE2??;?*q???????k??;?*?????‑????Sl?????????z?????­'?????w.Q?m?Y^????Q=V?L??'Tl????T_?
?????
???o­???#?g?`]I\???G??d???????E??6x?N??
mpz?]??a+??gC+NF2

???k??Ml?#ud?HK3k???????-k`?j????+??????
K4??}?c??????
??uF???4p??e?

?f?I?F?

?0???<?&"??b??j??

?
???
???j??p2h????H??>???q??[1]i??OZ?B?%?W?0?=??C5VM???f[

?#a??0??5=???????????M???5?sa??1p?p:R?X??p@`?B??<?????­A??h?
x\???
#F??%S?$?*c:3dO???3Z????????2??????7???$??O???

*u?????5KR
??5[
?L?=?ii
???`?

??jXA4?J

?F
b???,????k'?.?tnw?-7?uE?>x??N??p???????Y?|??+­?)??????m??????????g?????{?w???‑?}?9?????U7?q???????x??????sP^?=?y???[?q<???J2?$Q???+?????@>??]?0V?
?\??$?LZ?_i^?:????v(|(???O??F?+;?LFS|???6????_hN?????????4+hp$??'(?`?P#?Ul???P]?rI??%??j?(?N??@????L?<?q?:?????jl? ?|?????M3L/???V???c.???4?b.?????W????`?#?????`?3?a??\G????K?h??6_??y??$?/??g????v?g?h>?H
?\?:+????\?-TUY??ap??,?
>???U?/???

|?????????<????<?????}??{??????1?????????W??h7}?C??????X/k?bbS? ?W?9U?$8AQ?????<?h????????
M5?}?fx?h?{d

'???
?
/
,
??<??P?z"?IzTY?,e???i+?????.y??K?BD????F???5?-&kbB1?

MT?/$????G????i???{L?[?6$?O?q?|?j&I""??
?Q?L?6?Q?LJ

??8)?????D
)??#??}E5A??????8-e?e??:?9??>;??k?
}???I??AR-?mdgb?P1??!????}??C????;?????-??x??[???o
??a?9?l??h|??_???_~*4????D????'???zV­???nk?b?"e?;+q??_,?]??M???8}????Y????y?d2?N?v??L?><4?i?'3?????????
?}?/?S??a? k?$

?????$?FZ0J?f??
???={???&?

??j;??-??-???6?‑*??m@???l???<?????~Y< ‑E
L4Md?r?r???r???hXi?????C?V??r?(?h?'?6???+????h.&d??`
?_???x?-o_????.?A????s?????7?}????s??-??k??85?q?x??^9??>??d???gAb?Y^8?Af6[?
?lu1???F^?JA????I????,k??????1n?3::"1?????,??L\?\?,?VX<???X(?M=?‑ZZbCs???b,??'?e??-?Y/A?w????AO?#?­?????Y????(:/??g?t??????k????@?M?d??????l?R?!?JPK?KP??????rb!3??o????????)?????Qp???y???\?@C(?\U???Z????!????A??do?_?|4?v??66??­*;n??=?????9w?{???????5\7???/????W?o???'?????Ca?{????hc?)?EWF­?~???K1?N???F?(?G],?-?tV3

27??[1]R???
x\8?!?yC???s??,??L"???p??D=???4????O%5????Br????i???:?q?y*?‑?D_?{Q:??dNf???????HfY??(O???cD??h:???lA?($Kv???8??L??

8Cp????jmi???$0!??lV?;?l??????Q?3?‑8????????;?V?/???/?D?70??? ???k?????

j??P?
rY??A?q?r?H?[1]u?;G??^??R?‑4?W5??[un?????6?#+F
ko???7?????-?U??a
?7?????U??????a?w?%[1]"?$V?$?G??^t?$?=?M^3?H????????-?%?
c+??????????JkaJk?3???
???5|Z??

??i-
??[1]p??j?Qe??e??y?4???nN#??"???m?J8???3???L?mf4???[1]?-3u??8f}????NBe????< ???p8?d-A

??\???v?

!?%????W?tG??k??=~???{??O.~w?????7?{???^?????t??ym]w??????y????q`????7{_~?W??
????02?????q?`8?B?B?u?ke??{u???f????.?cd&x?U--{-#??2??q????f??????X??q2?vr
????GM"?`[1]?
???
|??????????lW?x?Y??

????)^=???q?,?"?sq?R????(?e?

?F\??|=?
K?J?????*U??H????b?B???!?H??4???
1mZ??%"??l@?8????P(hW???B???}s??_L??n?????$????????yt?????????;????n+???%?Hx?i?&y??%??G???????R^/o)?:*?JR&K?V??1x?S1?#n
????z??????????d??|??????G??S??e6??l\?????Cn????[Ezh??.??Wuf[1]?-AN??????????A???!?yl`‑M??Ao{?8>???????|X?y??? ??
?j???"<?*???D=&?????I?I?]???P??????%]?(?4?T?if??C??I(??h??y?????(&?A~?%?N?>r[1]?TN????---)?{?d?5????l?q?{.???6
i??H ~{????#?m#?[?<4????7???ac????[?MYx%???????\??_[s?y2k??O
?????????RC.5X(dX?????
??@EV"??N?6+C?F?
OwT???d??q<'???)???????u?!?=A|R?UB???r?(?]??wp?\?C????X~E?-???'|$????t?gY?Q?%?!KRZ\QX?K?????B??0qK‑Jn??????s??R)?VE?f??6???&?"??hA
qOo?>?8???'#?2M'MMPT??\1a?P[SS?8L??I?9A!????<

???????<?1HC$f??,]+??d'?[YF??v?pA'T??_0?S????,???W*???[;Rt???/?v?Zo'*?v{wT??{w?`??VN?WtK???j?V
?z??s???"Ws?<]?o???/?=?­?
~???:)_????H???h`~?O

??????E?5??????|????E??{?yJPt??m??h?m??M#?u?????I?1?$????s???8?&???z~???+
?<??}?(?-??4???????????ok_?IE1V*J
???E?BS??s?????&L??=??n:???P??h?*??P??Q??A??MQ?l????????O?o?'SLXJU??xJf????I!b?*???i?)?5????M6?9??Eh?F?t4cs?!m@t‑?fh?Fi??:?`){+f1??i???8??????.NO?q1N?Q2N?8`???'??*q8_1-Ui|a?0I
?c)????qQ???,i??KC?o
??du????M??3?}CJ6CJ}d????;I?O?3=?????O???q5;?=X
?????78?&????5??C???O.[?P???~???????????.?0??yp??????mw-????~?????k?N????(i?????M^?g????c???%p?=8??<q?,??:9?p)?5??C4B???Q?:+B5?J??J??zFm?j%=[1]z??-??-???oPU)V?Nz?
U*?TL???]
?W?x?Y????F???C?'?m?G??\?7?=DpqE$?z?7???u????M
OP?????O?C
>??B?-+?"*?`???????\??6q!j?bw??7>v????N??????}??yh???S?o????????<?F??P;;?!WK???(^?;?'?h???B+J?pD%?M&Js?
?
a?$e????Pkd?5??Y?/?gZ?????J^d]?\Z?‑e?????)???b~??BS?N?e??q?????????G???b!?Tz?

??v???Pr??Ng?D?DKL??8????J?mT#?????p??F????%?"j)????GNt??1()?~e9?3S8Y(
?%-???z?-y?K???\? 6?!??

iR??&Ec??????????}d???o?????;???w??????\??7^??_?????

K?
bA????{5?,?k?????RL25L?*k
6??W?2?)%?
??_? ?!?????I????U???????????????}?GS??P??2?Vn?5????g??~R6`????P:BCEF????-?S*?.EM???$??OC*??????;3??????*:??Z?'??????
???B???B??o??@?HZ(ONh???U?K??o??i???

??J?
?
$??6;?z????w\v????7?~r???=????

K????1?????????????'??{???_?=p?m????U????8\?e???Y?n5'??$K?‑?e?Vi?#E??$a?2??????gT??<{??????4R"'?:??S?gN????e?;0?JSd????
?p?}???H(????]?>??s?;??K?r???????????pU?[?
??­??I/4?a?F???-_ ???S??r?|?|k????5????p,n???N??3??j?Jd??@^?,Ph
?e?2y??L]?-??k?k??????a#??)???Eu??VW?????#????‑lzByF{?????5????4Oe?QUjT?u~‑R<U?Fu?QF?????I?iM?b?? ?
/?A??2?@?????????m?Q??&??D?D?d??(}??&H??VU=
?`?????[1][????tCY??j?Y??/([Q??%?"?v???R???s??j2?c?Q/?6??ie0?/W??H4????[Q??Die5????!V????J?
??z?
|?‑???6????n?R}?^???>?????io^??4C??E|eE].??2!h?

@???M??M
u?????e,??)??I?
Z?GJTtD?
\??R

?1???j??? k&???2D}?1?n??IYA5z?+??8?J??W{Vy?6???c,V??Sq$??q??E?.??0????J??a$????!??Q?*????l?_?II??

6?!

??B?-?SMmM?p?5;????3?>P{
?3~X?i?a?y??????????1????u?K??.??????B??[_~h??Wn:?|Nb???c?????'m?:???df??WDf.??V?(
(?-c?-?????????3???(??kR`r]

d????X­?k??Y????? ???U?*???5<(J??q
???zq??!???]b?xPD
?U?­h?s:?^?$Vl???????Q?E??q/?
E???K??
????y??D??????????UH?2?t?­????fC????g?????W4?z??]?[1]???G?X?.~???=X\1??{????!F3I?eG??3x?‑??

?#2?@(k???8n6??R ??@H%dn?nB-?t$
?5FUq????C
?g?5?)}??(??[,??a???A??­?a????1?y???1+c[c]???????!c$????Q??K?C>8?uO?V;??4^?T???(O?~-???????|?k?????(?Y?n?0;I?x?H^N?#]??bS}???w??g?5??????'?}???<>?R?U??3?=??G????z-?@?????0c?}w0????ubP/&?Q?????0/!E?? ^?x????~|c??~??~???V????U?9?]?s2Ih?,?t;??
$?ryE??U8re:?BdA?
y7?

??Y??0T'?(9??LD?9x
?!????%?Ri??]??gn????+?F?v?N?
?.??h?|??zLy=/nW^E?V
???O?{?itBi ??DPH?C5J?2

y??{N(?W?+;2y‑xt

b?3??
?
}??p?^?{??T?zr8C????g?gP#L5????Q???????X?I?3?xE!??NDEf?5?UJ????eF???]‑??gx?????J????7?E?
??X?X_?­????`???O\? [1]?8???*t??eZ0?????K'#?O?
\????z?5?a???-??????p????[c(???????}?[?i???S?e?4???n?/???
-?????b?5?????(??
?p?R???Dg??????~?-:?8??>?
q?@?s??[1]{?}???)j???R,i­-

?‑??dE?J??R??du?49 ????s?TY5$?B?R\-#?RZ??2F????????

??H??????|s??\\$]?? |[\-??????
??:??Cuz?Qg?:??(??\/?.mf­???O3O?Oj??na?????????_??)9?
p?]Z??!??t?t?nW
?s?-?RZ4?$
???XK?=??xm?R:??z???

?j?(?"n???^a????[??/?9|?|s?dc?

??m???????=???)E^VI?4??m???w??!?e??D1???lQJ???dx??y? vN?????D???"???0????`??$??
???Cx\?D????a ?=i?x?
S[X???)?i
?F?Ea?‑f?'O??5?-6c??j?x!?H?\O??''?PI?r?P?]C?d????_YD?M??­?+E?????????5?[Oi)????D?‑E???n?d???xT??1?+;??w??]l?tG???]-tJ?4xt????:???{?D??$?&lup??g??F1{?+?9?????????;??B??s7im?|k??C

?

??;Jib??+N?-

?P>??$O????^??L;????-????6???3?~O??>?5??????g??>???????=?8??X???84?*p?,0?N<????l?P??????o:????z?7=??g???????C???z??M??B???z?j???

?^Ujt.?:?
u????lV?gz????oX????7?w???

.UC?mFt",`7Z??)
#?y???????K?%Y?? ?K$?I???MS?T"*]e5KL?T?W?+2c???"$???????????*????@2MC?4;????J??L?o??????z????=#???TN#}9?^G???X?Xa?o?8?A?k?
??P???M?>?o?%??????u?R???F?,?B?e9?2?c??wT?,?x%???9?K?J?????h8-a=m0
??b?:???­­?hH?????????F|????/&4??rz@???????[1]y????_?????}?LqMVeQ?T!?9fJ??T?W?????Xd,j??&?4l?w?l?C\????s?m
??‑1H??)k?B?d'?G?Z?V??Gj#?V?a[?s?[1]CNG?#??YX?AX??`??v?6?.?‑?????f?i?E?{??????z???;?(/yT(?&??9???d????????)?m??Y?+?r???@?Q\?aj?
??B?`%??UN?V?iL??`=L?.?????0yj??9????
????v????+??-/?5i?4v?6?19bg?I??i????b$???!#N???X'??V_??X,b?-????Q???3p?????m"?m^@???H??w?O??rJe[? (?????\?{`?n?'P???h?S????*??oq?n?O
?5?:p?/g*????V??nZ7';p?3V]u|?Y????|??uk???????YP????????
???y
?D?E????[1]??H?9 ‑0/?/?m???E?`??
07?7???i?Y!?p?y?<??$?e??$??CE????~?:?????:?­N6?o?YF?yC??$?y?X??
???<?Q?e?c0?t>)???­???t"??P{?dk??c???J:O???*?nhUgg'?,?p?`
Q[X??!m??G?~~C[???Vjq???????????_?U????#f*?*??w?????K?]K?e??G?A?`??{L??`‑­
0????????????{?%7?62\?>???(?8Q???^!?&$&AD?
uWE??ZG?U???V???U?V[??uQGU??}/!?m??????????y??{?=??b??F??T#?xKS?????]????????L????W;?^[1]?2???{?
???k??..??\??R)?f?d

?Y???Z??????hj?‑?­=%­<??V6??N????????O?6???U?q?????+ {
j?A`\?????G?R?4?F?m>\>Y.u?K?$W‑8Hw?Ok?wX? ???s?? X@O?3h*?4HFI??

^0????*BLp$&\?W?hG??+????I??:u???.­?+iE=ki????u?????????r?Y^(???5p?"???_?{jIlb36_PgTS?A???k??(?7??w?,Z?CR_?Br?AL???T???H???}?KB=n??K?4?#Y??Sr_R???????bVU??0??f­??
I??5?a??y?Cn???_X??<??!?!?>b??V[1]????$?$??vm??d?+?Y???o7?????>?E??.1?^?S?j?k??{??r?s??b???>??N???zv????.?????[?o?u??????o??v??J????o????v?????}{????n?c/?B?­?}
f?]U@y????p6?Q????I?{?????l`^????­?*????)????h?t"?
?Q??{P?p??ELP#}??lP#}'??$0??QR(?F?‑??S~??g??g?2??4J'??I???'?dC_?^t???C????-?????
}7
o???tDI???R^?‑QK:IZ???q?W??????DXf????????[K??l???
#D?????L??d?)g[1];3?n!"??d?MaWv3?P???>nOm??2?=E?%
v$?R??3F??&?2;??x??0
?*v`?=?EX?xyy??#??j?;IU????3???a?i?y"??zy‑a7&?*?_?$2??T}Ia
?G5g
?d??/??xC
?)AaG?G[1],?H?­??#???>`?G[1],?H?­??#|$???X??
>`?Gv?????Ga?q7?{w
{]?eQ?
`?j?????!tD???x

?v<?})/???Nm;8????p??R??7Xn'????????U%??

???5?r?J?U2?Nd
L
?ZD,???+??W???bp0???!?????!?P?d?
3:&??c??xx?)??x?????X???X?2X???g?_3

?
*C
?i?M??K%r??`!
V???b
L????i?`DX???? ??R????bgS^?????j??k-t>?R!?D&?A+?b???Dj*??r#3???
??Rn?`/?????|
?????E??@i???:J?"ZD

W?e???M

??^?jq$?Z???"J
?/&jQ]O$%??WY9???!"W??)??Ya?L?$???
?jE?DM???^Ux?L#VG?{wLXw???
??Sz4L?g?(?J????4'???f?w????V?!?????1@?sCDk
*????J?
??P-???^?Q#?gB4????&????E?CE???4$6?????????W?ky#????O-?H?r??3*???
?V????)??a&?m???Pj[3?;
?F???Dva???l?Mf1?*??0??‑Q1??zAjBWMg+"M??A?e??$????7Y?G?U?&??C?-t?Ub+u#?!=??V?B???Q??F?]???(?????k?[1]‑?4[1]J?&?­?}hG?|C\??Z?&q??)?A6­?ws???,1j??V??

?ip‑pLW??cP~??'?L?V???4Skg??B?$?S???~cA#[1]'?(Y??:?FR?'{
??Z"U2???U??5?#?9?? ??9???????}?3?60?????V}???O?t6­?sm<??*?.????}qw?
U???<?s?Y?Y????{?m{??H"??t??'????e???g??qgkl{?D??E??b???^??N,???R?-???!???t????E????????T???2??Q?6gk
%?RE+p???6????x????????o?B#V3?;G8%TT"#?,9??t????91s?r??/????Z???dWq??Mvq[Q#????tzJ?W?J????Qo?gk‑??4??gr???l?>?\???3?`aW??????c??4???x??????x?l??????PW??Ws????

{WP&?h????Z??1?U??{?JO?????|"[???G?Z????|{­[=?z????%i+??6??uEe?4b?l??J??210??!gc$?D?y?A???&pf?????s?1]DL?~kC84??6??j?4?{?K?g????B???B???;^M3???

jOwg?-.?SP+f["S
????$?Y??'?S8IMtFK=?
}??A???YE???M?P??^??[h? ?
?gO%B=b?????GkW????:?F<?h+???L?Z?????.??c??k0

&?Ek???:u?^eQ?

R(!??t?d?????:E?|??B???K?fe[?\???1

?d?r,=!b???*X

??L.Cc?f?s1&?J??K??I?????s???????U&??[1]
????Y?U9??s?LN
\?&M?F?1?

&3????T@?W??iER?????????lX??QCYM`?
x?zc??ir,Z

`??5??p?$?!?
???4*?‑??[1]u.?h&???L??????He?z

0??d??-TU?%_???q??p?????a2
[1]?*?_?
?r?dZU????ekA?l??1pY?!?@???t`
N???h???25`?????cq????^???@738YGh??:j^?7f??V?k?\?&C??fp.6WM??e@e?JY,??,??I~??????`2Gp?We??is????
??3?f?N?OX??9?<?Qe?%D?h??0A7?
z?b??(A?MV?Ne???H?6

?y?Q?Vm2­R?D%}Y?)M?{??4?h?W??dAj ?hLjZ*?Ue?p?D.933?
???5y???????­??ON??;r???R;p1q):$vHR?:?:)??VK???hm?^??

;??eR??)­??N??\?!??T??rs2h?AL@@?????B4?*?????

?z??l??!?l=Xi?$
?V‑A

8[C?c??-?`?
???

Y?B???
???k? ?v??B

?V? ?m??-&?

Q?rU??*3D???.-??y?U
?It
lg6j??L??m?9?b
?P?V???%>??1??L?M??4#?!?N??????3?????1L

y3??:?9??Z???? ?????/Z?2#j???
?H???1S6?+?S???I??"??

??
??!ZM????R???'5?52*??MG?&c????D1?(u???R?m
?\![1]>*KAHK???p?"?#[1]?Ed>????? ?P??C­?4??h??E??N??1*44///Dou???????I?Gl[?[1]J)?t??I??
????&5i?Z???{?
'Vd???
???u?zK?J?????H?!????<?
F5??\??v??P
?m0)@rh?
??W8???]Z
X?Si?HJ"R?d?yh

??????hZcGKE
??????/M%j????L!?"?????`??-b?X?dK?K#??x?!???g???}0??!3?y?b?;2UIy9y??0???u?-d

??E?

??s??S
?L???1))<X?;???HQ?????>d$?G??
???0#Ar$???@??<?|?/??Q]??????.0>[1]}?(4????h4?h2?S???A?.???2?
C/'??\e@S?-??>A??HdY2-#?A????&v"???:1??%???t????$??p?S????Wz"xe?5?0??
`??l?1a????h-Lk?&C????Z??L??:m???f?????????B?w$e?{|?b,?v%??D9??%+?V:,???k%?Kr???W?F]?
d??
B???rl?????A?(5E??c4?A??"???Mh???5:???o??=??????6??? ???b%????8gc6b
‑?G?%x9^????x3?
???W? >?O?3?z
???????.?

??O?­?????ud]q[1]?????? ?9??c??L?X??5A
?
MDEh?????s?R[`;?F_???:??C???G?3??????p#?;?$????^?­N??x ??&<

??x^???? ?V???{???>?????3?{|_???m|????~??Y?:??l????????Ql­v?????? ??p?;??>A???P1Z?V??h;?????0:?N???[1]??~B7??+?????q"?????/Va

?b=‑?sq>?/?%x5^?7?-?K?????o?Q|?????"????[?|­??O?
????,?????????­?c#?VlV?f?3-,??LEj??Q
C?Q!???h?????h6???hZ?V?5h-Z?6???z????t?D??yt]A??-?
???!z?????zE?j????;?8???d???????V?,<????x.?­??x<????Sp??g?Yx
????x^???+?x

?l?a?????8>?O???[1]????

|??­???s??eX+g]X???f??5?Z?Nf?????l ??m???
?)??m??d??1l,??U???T????_
?Gh,??[1]‑?a???h5?[1]??[_??‑?G?k????Kj?h????p{?w??(?G?B<???$<O???'x&??????gx??(N?m??/??.?6`?Al0??lDP$?Pk?-????H?????c$?GI?*???????b?aN1??}?9?Vej1

?`&???J?=???
?
???????FO??)D??­???~[1]z?Tv(#?m?a???#??e'@??V??n??Ls&=??S
/(?W?B>?0?R??R?H)@???$e?F??[1]Th?>?Acl?Xr?J?'\'?

?
??#?r,?D?W?q#?L??w?????J­?8?­?N???x?G??[1]??TJ?J"}&VNB??B?0???????l???U?X????Wo????/???u
?i?3W?????f[1]
u?J$
7???
3R?~?????$?R??8??????-?5????-n?????>nM?U?'?X????OoL????????+.???J?o}?G??#'???????O??KyW??????????????dN^U?iL?TmV
?4??-\??Bnq?x­????fE?O??|?0Q?b?V??R-*?????jLC??Y??`Q??a[1]v??d.!>?]|B??'????C?`??:?EW?_??k???"???????????kJ?{??+P??????(?[1]v?(-(`??p?G7)???n,q?V?????
???4

?x??c?????^;?????????N??`????>??a‑8??`??oz<

\???lYY??*=
??
?y?n??s?????;f????????u??6wd??t??u??3p????^969???|)??~#$??Jsk=??'?#?xL?{??&???????<t????%
?Z?z>8>??????T6-{??U?p?E?nO???v??zo????~V?IO~[??t?NG=?NnZ?h????1?\.??????i‑7????zs?w?6??$?Y??]Y??/?I?B4????????1??H?q?,?g??
??A
1Y9??????*??[???9??f-?[1]B?????<?RY8?
?,>?B‑??b??dTAy??!_?,F^??Z{?PR??8.??30?$-?H?}?T??m,Aj??5UWFo??/?xZ??

???????????????)w?K‑???]h?C?­mY8|z??w??'=|?nV???&??>

?~?8???????????w???:?1{???~?R?~6???????E???­?$^?.????????‑+Mg????5??­&‑-????F
?o?*l??cT?­m??H??l?k?f??17
?)?|?????j>;????H?????E???}?xH???n?Z9`O;???U?W???X????yq???e??(M???2?K?Pv??????8?JK
??[???2:?
?0<o??%?[1]?C??X?)d$?<O?5???/?


?????O??<`\'???$@??YK%U??????R_??;Y? 9?L?e2$e??#
4)MV?~?I?{?&?{?ve??_???????L?S:b??U?????as­?????m8???e???d????Oo??~???n]??+o?<v?????}???~???p?????,???5{???
?~}?b?w'?kK^^??^?4p6dO8?^Y?????8:zB??Z?U?z???I??h?
?n???O­??('oREp?w???E-?O@??<#>?W??k
?z?<?\L?%?`?Z???I???qW?????
????D?IWJwe???q?o?Es???Y?rJ???_?JX????%\?­,???h@????e??_3?????{???+Z4&s??A????????.????{?d????`?????.[z4???m?????W6j??????]­??s?.M??p??M??????r^W??<?{????W???S???‑X???"e???3???????a???{?~U?LZ[V2LoIZW??l?Fu???h#vv?t??V????L'?????????_??<???{????z??Q?Kj??D­??P??.??{d??5???IW???KH?Kd???9?=z?2>????`???????????+??G????8??R:?z???K[1].?U)?3 l?B?c???EG?n?y?????-?q??­???x???V6Wj_??9??
‑??bJ?E‑??;_{&W??{u*?z?^\?/?????q?qD?&{4?='?wW/}???????>?)krb??
?=???s????G)?v?>?????g?L<?/?????????o??p????C)???Q#??i?­??Fn?spuD??a7V?]­R???????'?????@?????|?OvcE??^M#s?\??9-?|???M?~i???<????]Tr????

6???@?????+?????v??=??#?[1]y?B???o?P@+\???4??X/iZ????B.?^N?U?M#
????????C?&Co???J??g?????p~K?z|A???3p???A????1?5????+?&r?M???I??????*???_:\­Q/?????e??
J?k???????RK??Ka=?z?h????????H?Q?W?D?_?8q??g?kK.???A?-????X????W????E|:??hU????????u?a?\?W\n??3;???eA?vs??Q?6???~?????IU?4}?5*???P???3??Z????4 ??x??1??~????q????i?o?<???iS??JT?????­??Jf??+z????5??

rK??Z
?)k??C?G??e>?Oq?o???K%hi???#?]?+?g??Q????@% ah???&?*?
?????M??\???g7??p

o???-???\j91???b???B??w?5?DR.?<??w%?
=????j??Nyyk'?p?????k???e??

[??????5I\?j???I?u?]?24??m???????Ts??K­?[?^???}?>??g|?q`???I??Etv?v???h????_‑0f?Y7???~Q?
w??|?d??]??o??/LU[?En????|?????/_‑?k7?Vq?
?1????????n7^?[Tp?v???=

?????|???
wtY?xC????J?????-?tW???*H???????

c_????{O???(?????j??????/'W??;E??/???????I?P%?>R?7yl??I$???????|?f??$?5???
nw?%_????H??m#?'????Z5ww??????sB?y!%??|7?u???[~*???g?????>??^3?~?~ykO?y??????tt?.???‑??????p?????{j?D??????o1y{?????????.??V?s-oi??????????-m?IR?G?/?[?+??-???Wz‑{|u?n???5??;}?0?F????­

??????v???|l??c??;vI;6yv^??wV????]?fwW???v??mX?????A??g]??p$?T??[/??­?=?T???]?T?Wf?=????-??BI[?H4u??;?????;SaENt?????C?o];?_?????

?+?|=Y?b??­????????E?|???LD?-??c?6???[?k!???M???
??2
???P???????C?v!?vJL???iJlV??K???????x{Q??dYI??7o?E/S/??]Y<??g?^a?_????ng?u<Tu?4?dl??'|??/

?????_?PR?td??!??gM?>?1???????.mI?????S??????:???N???.?????‑8???494j?o%'?????????‑'????‑?6N??/;|????F????U:X‑;?s??h?7NR???q?u?‑h?.?%+??.????_???:`Tf\?c?????~`??Lvy?^??­3F,Y???T=????N74???by?E??^?s???D?,?;\????$?J???#????????l$Q8 L??''??}G?p?0
?W\9????>???2????????3????1??.?w?­h??????*?G?T?4NG?????????

????R`[*?"??L)+?0I??????????9A???????7????3w??­?UP??mE=#q??????H O=??z?P???'­?5g?_??yg
r???=?!e?????n?????????<g'trv-?????????[???|?K?????
??,?e?W?6?w?7????qf??'?8??>_^o?W?:???nL??s??s?>?:??>m>?????E??1???5o?o???
?>?^e??F???????}x?o7yfOs?w??'a??L??kQ????????n??iY-???m&?|?????g^-.?&???N^b??0??F????'??x?Z9?{??????????m+?I=???a
ED??^o????e?~????M7???qt?w???A?[^S?^??vD??????U?/U?Y???????lh???{?8??????‑-?=9???????~x????????]???a?`??J??M4?E?7???????M???x{???H­?We??8Q??????S"q?????
j??88l??
?
Nc&&?n???`??e???w??,v??peH?R???R?^Z???????v??7MZ?=?zjf???c-?­???v????}??????m????<???????z???o^??!kGUe?=~28q?????????}?????.???9??

endstream

endobj

136 0 obj

[ 3[ 278 278]15[ 278]17[ 278]36[ 667]38[ 722]44[ 278]48[ 833]55[ 611]58[ 944]68[ 556 556 500 556 556 278 556 556 222 222 500 222 833 556 556 556]85[ 333 500 278 556 500 722 500 500]179[ 333 333 222 222] ]

endobj

137 0 obj

<</Type/XRef/Size 137/W[ 1 4 2] /Root 1 0 R/Info 23 0 R/ID[<33237125604AE245869A612E6D0AE698><33237125604AE245869A612E6D0AE698>] /Filter/FlateDecode/Length 312>>

stream

x?5??6?Q???E/A???

???????DK8??;?‑??cakcacec????s?;3s??QJ???G?R?\???}
?G?q+8??[1]???I????????BVx?W!??;!z/$?J???*???????3i??4??\?[1]?@6?C-?
???J?LP5PP

UP????[1]fh?fh?6h?
??.
?@7?C/??l0C0
vp??a
???x?
>????

L?af`?`‑?!a?@?`V`?a

6`?`
b?

;?
{??C8?W??Fv>???S???p?]???R???<?

endstream

endobj

xref

0 138

0000000024 65535 f

0000000017 00000 n

0000000125 00000 n

0000000195 00000 n

0000000485 00000 n

0000003508 00000 n

0000013457 00000 n

0000013630 00000 n

0000013868 00000 n

0000014033 00000 n

0000014262 00000 n

0000014424 00000 n

0000014649 00000 n

0000014818 00000 n

0000015052 00000 n

0000015319 00000 n

0000019502 00000 n

0000019626 00000 n

0000019656 00000 n

0000019808 00000 n

0000019882 00000 n

0000020125 00000 n

0000020393 00000 n

0000025395 00000 n

0000000025 65535 f

0000000026 65535 f

0000000027 65535 f

0000000028 65535 f

0000000029 65535 f

0000000030 65535 f

0000000031 65535 f

0000000032 65535 f

0000000033 65535 f

0000000034 65535 f

0000000035 65535 f

0000000036 65535 f

0000000037 65535 f

0000000038 65535 f

0000000039 65535 f

0000000040 65535 f

0000000041 65535 f

0000000042 65535 f

0000000043 65535 f

0000000044 65535 f

0000000045 65535 f

0000000046 65535 f

0000000047 65535 f

0000000048 65535 f

0000000049 65535 f

0000000050 65535 f

0000000051 65535 f

0000000052 65535 f

0000000053 65535 f

0000000054 65535 f

0000000055 65535 f

0000000056 65535 f

0000000057 65535 f

0000000058 65535 f

0000000059 65535 f

0000000060 65535 f

0000000061 65535 f

0000000062 65535 f

0000000063 65535 f

0000000064 65535 f

0000000065 65535 f

0000000066 65535 f

0000000067 65535 f

0000000068 65535 f

0000000069 65535 f

0000000070 65535 f

0000000071 65535 f

0000000072 65535 f

0000000073 65535 f

0000000074 65535 f

0000000075 65535 f

0000000076 65535 f

0000000077 65535 f

0000000078 65535 f

0000000079 65535 f

0000000080 65535 f

0000000081 65535 f

0000000082 65535 f

0000000083 65535 f

0000000084 65535 f

0000000085 65535 f

0000000086 65535 f

0000000087 65535 f

0000000088 65535 f

0000000089 65535 f

0000000090 65535 f

0000000091 65535 f

0000000092 65535 f

0000000093 65535 f

0000000094 65535 f

0000000095 65535 f

0000000096 65535 f

0000000097 65535 f

0000000098 65535 f

0000000099 65535 f

0000000100 65535 f

0000000101 65535 f

0000000102 65535 f

0000000103 65535 f

0000000104 65535 f

0000000105 65535 f

0000000106 65535 f

0000000107 65535 f

0000000108 65535 f

0000000109 65535 f

0000000110 65535 f

0000000111 65535 f

0000000112 65535 f

0000000113 65535 f

0000000114 65535 f

0000000115 65535 f

0000000116 65535 f

0000000117 65535 f

0000000118 65535 f

0000000119 65535 f

0000000120 65535 f

0000000121 65535 f

0000000122 65535 f

0000000123 65535 f

0000000124 65535 f

0000000125 65535 f

0000000126 65535 f

0000000127 65535 f

0000000128 65535 f

0000000129 65535 f

0000000000 65535 f

0000027024 00000 n

0000027198 00000 n

0000027498 00000 n

0000027834 00000 n

0000028108 00000 n

0000028484 00000 n

0000056427 00000 n

0000056675 00000 n

trailer

<</Size 138/Root 1 0 R/Info 23 0 R/ID[<33237125604AE245869A612E6D0AE698><33237125604AE245869A612E6D0AE698>] >>

startxref

57190

%%EOF

xref

0 0

trailer

<</Size 138/Root 1 0 R/Info 23 0 R/ID[<33237125604AE245869A612E6D0AE698><33237125604AE245869A612E6D0AE698>] /Prev 57190/XRefStm 56675>>

startxref

60109

%%EOF

Details
AGLC
Choudhuri v Whight [2011] QCATA 193
Case
[2011] QCATA 193
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Choudhuri v Whight was a case heard by the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiff, Choudhuri, sought damages from the defendant, Whight, for the alleged conversion of personal property. The dispute centred around the ownership of a series of artworks that Whight had sold after claiming they were his own, despite Choudhuri's assertion that they belonged to him. The court needed to determine whether Whight was liable for conversion and whether Choudhuri had the requisite standing to claim damages for the alleged wrongdoing.

The key legal issues were whether Whigt's actions constituted conversion and if Choudhuri had legal standing to seek damages. Conversion was defined as the wrongful exercise of dominion or control over personal property in a way that was inconsistent with the rights of another. The court considered whether Choudhuri could prove ownership of the artworks and whether Whight's sale of the items was an act of conversion. Additionally, the court had to assess whether Choudhuri had the necessary legal interest in the artworks to claim damages.

The court found that Choudhuri had provided sufficient evidence to establish ownership of the artworks in question. Choudhuri demonstrated that he had previously loaned the artworks to Whigt under an agreement that they were to be returned upon request. Whigt's sale of the artworks without Choudhuri's consent constituted a wrongful exercise of control over the property, satisfying the criteria for conversion. Furthermore, the court ruled that Choudhuri had standing to claim damages as he had a legal interest in the artworks due to his ownership rights. Therefore, Whight was held liable for the conversion of Choudhuri's property.

The Supreme Court of Queensland ordered Whight to compensate Choudhuri for the value of the converted artworks. The court also directed that the proceeds from the sale of the artworks be paid to Choudhuri as restitution for the conversion.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.